Computational Brain & Behavior
Издатель: Springer Nature · ISSN 2522-0861 · 23 статей
-
Benchmarking Choice Consistency in Large Language Models: A Measurement-Theoretic Analysis of Transitivity Axiom
While large language models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed as decision-makers, current evaluation practice emphasizes benchmark accuracy rather than the structural properties that make decisions coherent and interpretable. We...
-
More than Just Measurement Models? Processing Insights from Population Coding Models of Visual Working Memory Retrieval
Continuous memory retrieval tasks provide a precise measure of visual working memory (VWM), but the mechanisms underlying their heavy-tailed error distributions remain debated. Recent population coding models (PCMs), including the...
-
Optimistic Update Bias in Response to False Information
We investigate the degree to which labelling information as true or false after exposure to it can influence the degree to which it alters beliefs and test whether valence (whether the information is better or worse than expected) plays...
-
Extending TVA With Trial-to-Trial Variability in Processing Speed: A Monte Carlo Simulation Study
The Theory of Visual Attention (TVA) typically treats processing speed as fixed within the modelled condition structure. This assumption may be too restrictive when effective processing speed varies from trial to trial. We introduce a...
-
A Cyber+Human Data Windfall to Revolutionize Cyberpsychology, Predictive Modeling, and Cyber Defense
The Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity (IARPA) Reimagining Security with Cyberpsychology-Informed Network Defenses (ReSCIND) program was a groundbreaking effort to revolutionize cyber defense using cyberpsychology; it...
-
Incorporating Re-retrieval into the ACT–R-based Cue Retrieval Model
This paper presents a revision of a recently proposed ACT–R-based cue retrieval model. Memory retrieval—the process of accessing information stored in memory—is often considered crucial to real-time sentence processing. For example,...
-
A Computational Model of Backward Reasoning in Human Problem Solving
When solving a problem with a clear goal, people often break down the problem into subgoals, a form of reasoning known as backward reasoning. The cognitive mechanisms of backward reasoning are poorly understood. Inspired by classic...
-
Memory Versus Generalization During Category Learning: An Extension of the Retrieving Effectively from Memory Model
This paper introduces an extension of the Retrieving Effectively from Memory (REM) model that supports both knowledge generalization and category learning. Simulation results demonstrate that core memory principles from REM can be...
-
Confirmation Bias in Adversarial Reasoning: Insights from the ASCEND Framework for Adaptive Cyber Defense
Cyberspace represents a dynamic cognitive battlespace where adversaries continually adapt to evade defenses. Traditional cybersecurity approaches emphasize technological countermeasures while overlooking the cognitive and behavioral...
-
Process Model Analysis for a Gamble Lottery Task
The Modular Serial-Parallel Network (MSPN) framework offers a comprehensive approach to understanding decision-making processes, particularly in the context of the classical gamble task. This framework facilitates the diagnosis of...
-
Leveraging Cognitive-Inspired Machine Learning to Understand Multi-Attribute Preference Construction
How people form preferences in naturalistic environments—where options are defined by latent attributes—is not well understood. We introduce a modeling framework that combines image embeddings with cognitively structured neural network...
-
Dissociating Reasoning and Planning through Markov and Quantum Metacognitive Dynamics
Online metacognitive processes support learning and decision-making by monitoring and integrating heuristic cues, such as evidence variability and conflict, throughout deliberation. Certain computational approaches, such as Markov and...
-
Towards the Definition and Measurement of Routines and the Cognitive Processes that Underpin their Maintenance
The benefits of routines for daily functioning are widely acknowledged, yet, despite their apparent importance, methods for quantifying routine maintenance and the causes of their disruption remain lacking. Here, we propose a novel...
-
Beyond the Curve: Visual Working Memory and the Illusion of Understanding
Good fits of models can produce an “illusion of understanding” when the models lack grounded theoretical interpretations. This is characterized by the recent claims surrounding the good fit of the Target Confusability Competition (TCC)...
-
Response to Commentaries to “Illusions of Understanding in the Sciences”
The commentaries to the essay “Illusions of Understanding in the Sciences” added important perspectives, citations to relevant research, and in some cases alternative views. The number of commentaries (32) make it impossible to respond...
-
Scientific Misunderstanding: Notes for the Bedeviled
In this paper, we critically examine the essay by Shiffrin, Stigler, and Keil (2026) on scientific understanding. We argue that, despite its uncontroversial moral message, the paper largely fails to articulate a compelling thesis. The...
-
Collective Illusions of Understanding in NeuroAI
Large language models and other deep neural networks often mimic human behavior well, which has led to strong claims about human and machine intelligence alignment. We argue that such claims reflect an illusory understanding of human...
-
Whose Illusion? Causal Inference is Fundamental to Data Analysis and Cognition
The authors (SSK) make wholesale claims that scientists and lay people suffer not only from misunderstandings, but more dangerous illusions of understanding. However, their case is only supported by intuitive examples rather than solid...
-
All Illusions Are Wrong, but Some Are Useful
While we agree with the general argument of Shiffrin and colleagues (2026) that scientists fall prey to the illusion of knowledge, we disagree with their argument that illusions present a fundamental problem for science. We argue that...
-
Don’t forget the world outside the lab – a comment on “Illusions of Understanding in the Sciences”
The article “Illusions of Understanding in the Sciences” by Shiffrin et al. (2026) describes ways in which scientists can mislead themselves and others about the extent to which they understand the (causal underpinnings of) phenomena...
-
Combatting Meta-Ignorance in Science Through Dialogs with Diverse Experts
In their provocative paper, Shiffrin, Stigler, and Keil (SSK) declare that scientists have illusions of understanding the phenomena they study “more deeply” than they really do. In this comment I grant their claim a degree of truth and...
-
Uncovering Illusions of Understanding: A Falsificationist Perspective
In a complex world, scientific explanations are always incomplete. Therefore, can we say that scientists generally suffer from “illusions of understanding?” I argue that embracing a falsificationist perspective makes scientists aware of...
-
Tukey’s Warning and Pascal’s Wager
We comment on an article by Shiffrin, Stigler, and Keil (2026) relating illusory beliefs of understanding to hubris, discussing the dangers associated with accepting a model as a lawful fact and the benefits of questioning one’s models.